When it comes to defining your eyes, eyeliner is a non-negotiable in any beauty routine. Whether you're chasing a sharp wing, a smoky gaze, or the perfect waterline definition, choosing the right eyeliner formula makes all the difference. At Mirabella Beauty, we offer three professional-grade options: the Eye Definer Eyeliner Pencil, Eye Crayon, and Magic Marker Liquid Eyeliner—each designed to help you master any look with ease and confidence.

In this guide, we’ll break down the differences and best uses of each to help you discover the best eyeliner for your style, eye shape, and skill level.

Eye Definer Eyeliner Pencil – Best for Waterline & Smoky Liner Looks

Searching for the best eyeliner pencil for tightlining or creating a soft, smudged look? Our Eye Definer features a smooth, semi-solid gel texture with a matte or metallic finish. It's ideal for:

• Tightlining and waterline application (yes, it's waterline-safe!)

• Smoky eyeliner looks

• Layering under powder shadows

Pro Tip: Warm the pencil tip on the back of your hand for smoother application and blend quickly before it sets. Sharpen and sanitize between uses for pro-level hygiene.

Eye Crayon – Best for Graphic Liner & Smoky Eyes

Available in Blackmail and Champagne, our Eye Crayon is a creamy, chubby pencil perfect for graphic liner, color blocking, and editorial makeup looks. With its luminous or deep kohl finish, it’s a favorite among makeup artists for:

• Quick smoky eye creation

• Brow bone and inner corner highlights

• Bold, runway-ready designs

Application Tips:

• Use sparingly on smaller lids

• Set with translucent powder or eyeshadow for all-day wear

• Blend with a brush for sharp definition

Magic Marker Liquid Eyeliner – Best for Cat Eyes & Precision Work

Love a crisp winged eyeliner or cat eye? The Magic Marker is your go-to. This liquid eyeliner delivers a highly pigmented, fast-drying formula with a precision marker tip for:

• Classic wings and flicks

• Bold graphic eyeliner looks

• All-day smudge-proof wear

Use the tip’s point for ultra-fine lines or the side for bolder strokes. Apply in small sections and store cap-down to prevent drying for best results.

Choosing the Right Eyeliner for Your Eye Shape

Wondering which formula flatters your eyes the most? Here's a quick guide:

• Hooded Eyes: Keep it close to the lash line with Eye Definer or create an open-eye wing with Magic Marker.

• Monolids: Build above the lash line or use Eye Crayon as a smoky base.

• Round Eyes: Elongate with smudged corners (Eye Definer) or tapering wings (Magic Marker).

• Downturned Eyes: Focus on lifted corners with the Magic Marker.

Finding the right eyeliner for your eye shape can be a challenge.  Cosmopolitan's guide to applying eyeliner correctly on every shape is a great resource to learn more about this concept. 

Pro Tips from Mirabella Makeup Artists

• Mix and match textures for multidimensional eye looks.

• Use Eye Crayon as an eyeshadow base.

• Seal crayon formulas with powder to lock in all-day wear.

• The Magic Marker dries quickly—so plan your moves!

Why Choose Mirabella Eyeliners?

All three formulas are designed for professional performance, clean beauty standards, and long-lasting wear. Whether you're a seasoned pro or a beauty lover at home, Mirabella has the tools you need to create any eye makeup look—from everyday definition to avant-garde artistry.

Explore Mirabella Beauty’s full eyeliner collection and elevate your eye game today.