i had black under my eyes that afternoon
Store owner replied: Mascara smearing can be caused by a number of factors, and it doesn’t necessarily mean there’s an issue with the mascara itself. Skin type, natural oils, humidity, heat, skincare or eye creams, makeup application, and even individual lash shape can all affect how mascara wears throughout the day. Everyone’s skin and eye area is different, so a formula that stays perfectly in place for one person may transfer or smudge more easily for another. For best wear, we recommend allowing skincare and eye products to fully absorb before applying mascara and avoiding applying heavy creams or oils too close to the lash line.